AI Writing Tools Compared 2️⃣ Desktop App or Web Tool for Writing a Novel? SoloEnt vs. Sudowrite
Our last post, ChatGPT and Claude Can Write Novels Too. Why Use SoloEnt?, covered the limits of writing in a chat window. Today we'll tackle the question writers care about most when choosing a tool: if you write on a computer, how do SoloEnt and Sudowrite differ, where does your manuscript live, and how are versions managed?
Platform: the two products have different focuses.
SoloEnt focuses on the desktop, with clients for Windows 64-bit and macOS (both Apple silicon and Intel).
Sudowrite is a web app. You use it in the browser, so it runs on any computer, and a tablet browser works too.
Layout and storage: local versus cloud makes a big difference.
In SoloEnt, every book is its own folder saved directly on your computer. The interface has three panes: the left manages worldbuilding, characters, outline and chapter files; the middle is a Markdown editor that supports viewing across two or more screens; the right is the Agent chat. You can also open multiple windows to run separate projects side by side without interference.
Sudowrite stores your work in the cloud, which means bringing your existing material in, or getting finished chapters out, goes through import and export. In exchange you get an all-in-one browser workspace organized around its Story Bible, with nothing to install.
Version management: a local repository versus a cloud account.
In SoloEnt, you can initialize your workspace as a local Git repository. Each time you finish an outline or a batch of chapters, the built-in commit summary feature generates a commit message and saves a checkpoint. If you later dislike the AI's changes, you can roll straight back to an earlier checkpoint.
With a cloud-based web tool, your safety net is whatever history the service keeps in your account, rather than a full, local version history you control.
To sum up: if you value control over your local files, like multi-screen Markdown editing and version rollback, the SoloEnt desktop app is the better fit. If you prefer writing in the browser or on a tablet and want an all-in-one guided workspace, Sudowrite may suit you better.
Follow along with the series. Next time, we'll keep comparing desktop and web writing products on model choice and pricing, again using SoloEnt and Sudowrite as examples.