AI Novel Writing Basics 5️⃣ Not Happy with Your First Draft? How to Revise Effectively with AI
Last time we covered getting AI to draft chapter one from your outline. Once it's generated, what if the opening doesn't grab you, the characters don't match what you imagined, or something else is off? How do you get it to the version you have in mind?
If you just tell the AI "make it more exciting" or "speed up the pacing," the new version may still miss the mark, and you'll likely burn a lot of tokens for nothing.
To get revisions closer to what you want, you need to spell it out: exactly where the problem is, how big the change should be and what needs to stay.
First: figure out which layer the problem is in.
Start by checking three areas: story, character and expression.
Story: what does the protagonist set out to do in this chapter? After acting, has the situation changed?
Character: are the protagonist's choices consistent with their established history and motives? Do they suddenly know things they shouldn't, just to move the plot along?
Expression: is there repeated explanation, overlong description or too much focus on detail?
Each of these calls for a different kind of revision.
Find the problem first, and the revision has a clear direction.
Second: tie your impression to specific passages and their effect on the reader.
"The pacing is slow" is a reading impression. What you need to figure out is where it's slow and what's making the story stall.
Say the chapter is about the protagonist receiving a message from a witness while investigating a case and getting ready to go meet them. But the text first spends a long stretch on her education, family and how she got the job, and takes forever to reach the meeting.
You could give feedback like this:
"Get into the plot first. Move up the message and the meeting with the witness, and fill in background later as the plot requires."
You can handle character and language problems the same way.
"In this dialogue, the protagonist volunteers her entire investigation plan to a stranger, which doesn't fit her cautious character. Adjust her answers so she holds back and gathers information by probing instead."
Compared with just saying "the character's off," feedback like this maps directly to a concrete change.
Third: say what to keep and where the boundaries are.
When you give revision notes, also tell the AI what's already working.
If there are truths that can't be revealed yet, or characters and setups you don't want added, say so explicitly.
In SoloEnt, you can select a passage, quote the text that needs changing, then explain what that passage needs to do and your requirements.
For whole-chapter structure, discuss an adjustment plan around the full chapter first.
Fourth: for structural problems, agree on a plan before rewriting.
If you need large-scale changes, like reworking the chapter's plot, the characters' motives, or rewriting the whole chapter, review the chapter first.
Focus on three questions:
Is the protagonist's goal clearer?
Do the events connect through believable cause and effect?
Does the change affect plot points you've already settled later on?
You can also ask the AI for revision ideas, for example: "I want to rewrite this chapter's plot. Keep the character relationships and later events we've already settled, and help me rebuild the current plot, but don't write it yet. Give me revision directions first."
Once the plan is confirmed, move on to revising the prose. For language, punctuation or local repetition, just point to the spot and give a specific request.
Feedback like this puts the problem, the goal, what to keep and the steps to take all in one place.
After revising, reread the chapter to check whether the original problem is solved and whether any new contradictions have appeared. If the direction is right, keep refining the dialogue, description and word choice.
Revise in rounds. In each round, tackle the problem that hurts the reading experience most right now, with clear reasoning and a clear goal.
When you discuss revisions with AI, the more specific the problem you point out, the easier it is to find a fix that works.
Got it? Next time we'll talk about what records to keep after finishing a chapter so the next one can use them, and how to keep moving steadily from chapter to chapter.