Finding Your Premise 3️⃣ How Do You Turn a Bestseller Formula into a Premise That's Truly Yours?
Last time, in Read Dozens of Books from the Rankings and Still No Ideas?, we covered how to take notes on sample books from the rankings.
Plenty of writers have a pile of breakdown notes, but freeze when it's time to start a new book: follow the bestseller formula and you risk a reskinned copy; change it too much and you lose the payoff that made it work.
Breaking down a model book just shows you the core formula. To turn that formula into your own premise, follow the steps below.
Step 1: Switch to Plan mode and brainstorm across boundaries.
When you start a new conversation in SoloEnt, switch to Plan mode first. It's cheaper and keeps things organized.
Before you start, be clear about what you want from your new book, then ask the AI to suggest three to five directions based on current trends and the model book's payoffs.
This is the time to step boldly outside the original genre: move the core conflict into a different era or profession, such as workplace drama, family intrigue or xianxia, or a traditional herbalist, a blind piano tuner, or a young factory worker who moved to the big city in the 1990s.
If you already have an idea, give the AI a one-line concept to develop, and decide whether you're going for a small twist in the same genre, a logic transplant, or something completely open.
Step 2: Don't just swap the profession and era. Dig for what makes it different.
In our testing, many models brainstorming across genres change the surface to, say, a 1930s spy thriller or Hollywood, while copying the skeleton wholesale. Don't just click through and let the AI spit out a result. First ask why the original's payoff works, then layer on a new mechanism.
For example, keep the core payoff but add a trapped-in-a-book twist or a dual mystery storyline, so the protagonist and the power hook collide in new ways. In our experience, strong reasoning models are good at digging into the logic and finding a distinctive angle, while lighter, faster models keep the back-and-forth clear at a lower price per token. Pick what suits you.
Step 3: Refine over several rounds and land a premise document.
Once the direction is set, keep going back and forth until the idea becomes a premise document of one or two thousand words. Work through each item with the AI: the protagonist's identity and history, the power hook's core function and conditions for using it, the roles of key supporting characters, the era and map, and the core selling points. Also check that the power hook makes sense and won't derail the main plot.
When everything checks out, switch back to Act mode and save the premise document to your project files.
Now read your new premise document. Does it have that bestseller feel, while being entirely original?
What if the hottest genre on the rankings is one you've never written and don't even like reading? Next time: The Hottest Genre Isn't One You Write or Read. Should You Chase It Anyway?
Follow along with the series.